Eaton Street Seafood Market: Fresh Seafood Fare in Key West

TWICE IN ONE DAY!! We came back for dinner! Fish was excellent!! Outside seating is limited- and place was super busy- but we ordered the grilled tacos, crab cake sandwich, and the Ahi tuna sandwich which was in the seafood case- all 3 were excellent!! Great Cole slaw too! Definitely come hungry!

I got a cold lobster roll with coleslaw and it was STUFFED with amazing fresh lobster. They have cold or hot options. 10/10 will be going back when I get a chance to go to Key West!!

The staff members were very efficient, knowledgeable and helpful to all customers. We dined inside die to the rare cold spell. The ladies working were so pleasant and helpful. If you want a no frills venue with the best prices and quality, Eaton Street Seafood is the place. Super fresh stone crab claws were less than 1/3 the price of any other restaurant. Do you want quality seafood or the fluff for 3X the price? Both are good sometimes. You owe it to yourself to gone it a try!

Small off the main street establishment. I wanted the freshest Stone Crab Claws and Conch Fritters in Key West and was not disappointed.They happened to be out of the large claws so we opted for Colossal. All sizes arrived as we were eating but not a problem because the taste is tbe same just bigger Claws. The young lady that waited on us was excellent in all her explanations and description of all the selections of seafood. Small eating area beside parking lot with picnic tables so you can eat onsite or get takeout. Fresh selection you can get prepared or take home to cook. You can also order online.

The lobster plate was amazing and actually ended up being enough food for a larger guy. We also got both chowders and the crab cakes and everything not only exceeded expectations but actually felt like an awesome deal after the mayhem that is Duval St! This feels like a place the locals go and I'm already planning my next visit. Thanks so much to the amazing team working yesterday that made this one of our favorite surprises of the trip!

Food was excellent!!! As someone who doesn’t eat fresh fish like this often, when I asked the girl working for help it somewhat seemed like an inconvenience to educate me on the different fish, but I ended up with the blackened snapper tacos & it was great! 2 people in my party had stone crab & they were thrilled. Outdoor eating was perfect!

Very cosy food corner with a great variety of dishes. The lobster roll was really good, the starters were also good. The only negative thing was the wine which was undrinkable. Besides that and if you avoid the wine, the place is really nice.

Came here on my birthday and lobster roll is my favorite food… so high expectations. And they absolutely nailed it! Delicious cold Maine lobster roll with a perfectly buttered bun. Very nice lady running the place and I believe some very fresh seafood for sale inside including snow crab claws! Loved it and highly recommend